One i'm favouring at the moment is the Sainsburys own mature cheddar (in blue packaging); has nice cheese … We’re sharing our thoughts on all eight cheeses, as well as our favorite national brand of cheddar … About our Extra Mature and Delicious Cheddar. Asda own brand is ok, but not a good taste of cheddar cheese in my mouth when I have it, or a cheesy aftertaste. Cheddar cheese is a go-to snack, but it also has a well-deserved place in grilled cheese sandwiches, macaroni and cheese, nachos, chili, and so much more. Collier's powerful cheddar has a distinct texture, open, slightly crumbly, yet smooth and creamy in the mouth. So it was high time we took a trip to the store and tested all the big brands of cheddar we could find. It’s a fine sharp cheese, but it lacks the backbone to be called “extra sharp.” Still, it’s preferable to Lucerne’s sharp cheddar, which is bland with a slight plastic flavor. The Best Cheddar Cheese You Can Buy at the Supermarket From yellow to white and squishy to firm, we tasted nine grocery store cheeses to find out which one deserves to be our go-to. Our bestseller, this tangy, full-flavoured, well-rounded Cheddar takes as long as 12 months to reach its peak. Unusually, it contains tantalising "crunchy bits" which are actually calcium lactate grains that develop during maturation and are evidence of the cheese… Highly versatile, you can simply enjoy it … Tickler is good but a bit expensive, Cathedral City I find tasteless. …